Chapter 3 : Managing Air Emissions

 (Photo 3.1) We need a continuous supply of fresh air  to remain healthy.

We need a continuous supply of air  and  an environment with adequate air quality to remain healthy – an individual requires around 10-20 m3 of air per day on average.  The quality of  air depends on the levels of various kinds of emissions from natural sources and human activities.  The most common pollutants are sulphur dioxide (SO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), carbon monoxide (CO) and total suspended particulates (TSP). These are classified as primary pollutants (due to the fact that they are emitted directly into the atmosphere). There are also other pollutants, called secondary pollutants, such as the tropospheric ozone (O3), which results from chemical reactions among primary pollutants.

The Hotel Industry’s Contribution to Air and Noise Pollution

(Photo 3.2) One source of CFCs comes from fire- extinguishers. (Photo 3.3) Bacteriological pollutants can easily be found in cooling towers.

Some ways that the hotel industry contributes to air and noise pollution are as follows:

Air pollutants

Sources

CFCs (chlorofluorocarbons)

• Freon loss from refrigerators, chillers, self-contained coolers.
• Use of CFC-containing spray cans.
• Fire-extinguishers

Emissions from burning fossil fuel or gas • Boilers for the generation of steam and hot water.
• Vehicles.
• Gas-fired equipment in kitchens and laundries.
• Indirectly by consuming energy delivered from power stations.
• Electricity generators ( for emergency power).
Emissions from the evaporation of hydrocarbons • Use or spillage of petrol, diesel oil.
• Pesticides (chlorinated hydrocarbons).
Odours, vapours and mists • Kitchen and laundry exhausts.
• Toilet exhausts.
• Paints (especially spray) and solvents.
Bacteriological pollutants • Cooling towers.
• Swimming pools.
• Waste disposal.
• Stores, kitchens and bathrooms.
Particulates • Asbestos.
• Lint (laundry).
• Sawdust.

 

Why Should You Tackle Air Pollution ?

The aims are to conserve fossil fuels and to produce fewer emissions, which will:
1)Provide a healthier environment for employees and guests.
2)Contribute to the conservation of the environment.
3)Reduce expenses by cutting fuel bills and prolonging equipment life.

 

Ways You Can Help

 
The major approach is to reduce emissions at source, reduce consumption and to switch to less harmful products
 and systems, and more efficient technology.  The key stages are:
 1) To identify equipment, materials, processes and operating procedures that contribute to harmful emissions.
 2)To assess the entire building and its contents with regard to hazardous emission and concentration levels.
 3)To develop a realistic action plan.

 Some examples are suggested as follows:

(Photo 3.4) Electrostatic precipitator equipped with auto-cleaning system is the most preferable type of greasy fume control equipment. (Photo 3.5) Install suitably sized stoves that meet operational requirements.

a. Housekeeping and Laundry


• Use biological pest control or use physical methods e.g. use UV light to attract insects to electrical exterminators and flame guns to control weeds.


• Where application of chemical pesticides and herbicides is unavoidable, select the less harmful chemicals e.g. some insect sprays are based on pyrethrum, a natural insecticide obtained by extraction from chrysanthemum flowers.
Details of environmentally friendly use of pesticide and herbicide can be found in Chapter 8.


• Explain to the colleagues concerned the recommended operating procedure of the ozone air purifier from the product instruction sheets.


• Use non-aerosol packaging such as pump dispensers, which are just as effective as aerosols for spray cans containing spot-cleaning liquids, bathroom and other surface cleaners, paints, pest and other plant sprays.

 b.Restaurant and Kitchen

• Convert all refrigerants of the kitchen equipment to CFC-free substances .

• Install efficient greasy fume control equipment to treat kitchen emissions prior to their exhaust e.g. use of
electrostatic precipitators (EPs), water spray hoods, air washers, packed scrubbers, etc.

• Use odour and volatile organic compound removing technology such as activated carbon filters.

• Install suitably sized stoves that meet operational requirements. Inappropriate design and layout of cooking devices will not only increase emissions of air pollutants but also waste energy.

• Install separate exhaust systems for handling emissions from those cooking processes that may generate strong odours to prevent over-loading the control equipment.

• Install thermostats in frying equipment to prevent overheating of cooking oil and reduce greasy fume emission.

• Place exhaust outlets in proper locations in order for the emissions to thoroughly disperse into the atmosphere and to avoid nuisance to the neighbourhood.

• Properly operate and maintain the air pollution control devices to ensure that they are functioning normally. Clean the equipment frequently and check the parts on a regular basis.

• In kitchens, air pressures must be slightly negative.

(Photo 3.6) Avoid all products manufactured with CFCs such as foams, aerosol sprays. (Photo 3.7) Improve efficiency of boilers by adjusting air / fuel ratio and regular maintenance. (Photo 3.8) Retrofit emission control devices such as particulate traps.
(Source: Environmental Protection Department, Hong Kong).
 c.Engineering and Maintenance

• Avoid all products manufactured with CFCs such as foams, aerosol sprays, fire-extinguishers and solvents. Replace the chemical with an alternative without completely replacing the equipment (See Table 3.2) or purchase new equipment with the use of alternative refrigerants.


• Frequently leak-test refrigerating systems, especially when loss of capacity is obvious, from temperature loss or constant operation of compressor. Perform regular checks with electronic leak detectors or simple soap solution (apply soap water to refrigerant coils and hoses, the bubbles show where there are leaks).


• Reduce energy consumption through better insulation, heat recovery, energy efficient lights, computerised controls, efficient equipment and other modern technology items. Details can be found in Chapter 7.


• Use a freon recovery unit to remove freon from the system, condensing it so that it can be stored for re-use. This process removes virtually all the refrigerants in the refrigerator, reducing CFC emissions, and saves money on the cost of repurchasing refrigerants.


• Improve efficiency of boilers by adjusting air / fuel ratio and regular maintenance.


• Recondition diesel-burning boilers to use clean energy such as natural gas or cleaner fuel oil, for example, with sulphur content, less than 0.5%.

d.Vehicle Fleet

• Investigate the possibility of reducing driving by using public transportation, car pooling, other communication means (phone, fax, telex).


• Plan your journey using the most direct, least congested route.


• Switch off engine while idling to avoid exhaust gas from polluting the environment.


• Do not over rev the engine in low gear. Pulling away too fast will produce more air pollution than gentle acceleration.


• Buy Euro III or above standard for hotel vehicles, which consume less petrol and emit less pollutants, or even vehicles with alternative fuel or power source if possible.


• Clean and replace air filters regularly.


• Check the engine and exhaust system promptly if you notice a change in the way your vehicle, functions, fuel efficiency drops or a warning light goes on.


• Check the fuel injection system according to manufacturer’s recommendation. Fouled fuel injectors reduce fuel efficiency, make the vehicle more difficult to start and drive, and significantly increase pollutant emissions.


• Keep the tyres properly inflated and check the pressure every two weeks. Maintaining the proper pressure saves money, reduces pollution and is safer.


• Check the coolant level weekly by observing the overflow tank. Never remove the radiator cap unless the engine is completely cold.


• Retrofit emission control devices such as particulate traps or catalytic converters to the hotel vehicles (see photo 3.8).

(Photo 3.9) With exhaust hood design type, electrostatic precipitator can be installed directly above the cooking stoves. There is no need to install it outside the restaurant.

Ozone Depleting Susbtances

CFCs are commonly used as refrigerants in refrigerators and air conditioners and as
propellants for aerosol sprays, etc.  Halons are used as fire extinguishing agents.
Traditional refrigerants can be found in Table 3.1

The ozone molecules in stratosphere absorb the sun's ultraviolet radiation (UV),
which will be harmful to us if it reaches the earth’s surface.  With more UV radiation 
reaching the earth’s surface due to ozone depletion by ozone depleting substances,
 
human health and the environment would be adversely affected. The most significant

effects would be the increased incidence of skin cancer, eye cataracts, damages to the
 
human immune system and to the ecology of the earth.

A recent international expedition found that half of Antarctica's ozone has disappeared over a region twice the size of the United States, creating an enormous "hole" in the ozone layer.

If possible, replace the traditional refrigerants with the substitutes listed in Table 3.2

\

Table 3.1 – Traditional Refrigerants

Symbol
Refrigerant Name/ composition ODP*
Atmospheric life (years)
CFC-11 R-11 Trichlorofluoromethane 1.0 60
CFC-12 R-12 Dichlorofluoromethane 1.0 120
CFC-113 R-113 1,1,1-trichlorotrifluoroethane 0.8 90
HCFC-22 R-22 Chlorodifluoromethane 0.05 120
  R-502 Blend of HCFC-22 and CFC-115 0.34  
Halon H1211 CF2CIBr 3.0 25
Halon H1301 CF2Br 10.0 110
Halon H2402 C2 F4Br 6.0 28
(Source : A more extensive list is available on the Internet at http://www.unepie.org/ozonaction.html)
* Ozone Depleting Potential (ODP) relative to CFC-11 (OPD=1.0) – the extent to which CFCs destroy the layer of ozone is known as ODP

 

Table 3.2 – Main Substitutes for Traditional Refrigerants and Other Ozone Depleting Substances

Symbol Refrigerant Name/ composition ODP* Atmospheric life (years)
HCFC-123 R-123 2,2-dichloro-1,1,1-trichloroethane 0.02 2
HFC-134a R-134a 1,1,1,2 tetrafluoroethane

0

16
  R-401A Blend of HCFCs 22/124 and HFC-152a (53/34/13 weight%) 0.036  
  R-401B Blend of HCFCs 22/124 and HFC-152a (61/28/11 weight%) 0.04  
  R-402A Blend of HCFCs 22/125 and propane (38/60/2 weight%) 0.021  
  R-402B Blend of HCFCs 22/124 and propane (60/38/2 weight%) 0.033  
  R-404A Blend of HFCs 125/134a and 143a (44/4/52 weight%) 0  
  R-406A Blend of HCFCs 22/124 and isobutane (55/41/4 weight%) 0.057  
  R-407A Blend of HCFCs 32/125/134a (20/40/40 weight%) 0  
  R-407C Blend of HFCs 32/125/134a (23/25/52 weight%) 0  
  R-408A Blend of HCFCs 22/124 and HFC-152a (53/34/13 weight%) 0.026  
  R-409A Blend of HCFCs 22/124/142b (60/25/15 weight%) 0.048  
  R-410A Blend of HFC 32/125 (50/50 weight%) 0  

NH3

R-717 Ammonia 0 Less than 1
CH(CH3)3 R-600a Isobutane 0 Less than 1
HC-290 R-290 Propane 0 Less than 1
(Source : Internet at http://www.unepie.org/ozonaction.html)
* Ozone Depleting Potential (ODP) relative to CFC-11 (OPD=1.0) – the extent to which CFCs destroy the layer of ozone is known as ODP

 

(Photo 3.10) The performance of water spray hood and air washer is directly related to the design of the equipment.
Box 3.1 - OVERVIEW OF GREASY FUME CONTROL TECHNOLOGIES


Greasy fumes emitted from hotel kitchens may cause a negative impact on neighbouring residents. Using suitable air pollution control measures can improve the quality of kitchen emissions. The commonly available greasy fume control measures include:


a . Electrostatic Precipitators (EPs)


EPs are the most preferable type of greasy fume control equipment. They effectively collect oil mist and the removal efficiency exceeds 90%. Kitchens that involve frying processes are advised to adopt this equipment for the control of greasy fumes.

EP uses an electrostatic field to remove greasy fumes. Airborne particles or liquids are electrically charged under an intense electric field and then collected by charged collector plates. Since the accumulation of grease on the collector plates reduces the removal efficiency, EPs should be cleaned and serviced regularly.

Hotels should consider choosing the EP models equipped with auto-cleaning systems because these systems can regularly eliminate the grease accumulated on the collection plates. As a result, this type of EP can maintain high removal efficiency without the need for frequent cleaning. EPs can be divided into two categories: duct type and hood type. These two types of EPs have their own advantages and both can achieve high oil mist removal efficiency.


b. Water Spray Hood and Air Washer


Water spray hoods (hydrovents) are used to remove oil particles, smells and fumes generated from cooking. When greasy fumes are passing through the water curtain, the oil particles are removed by the water flow.

Although water spray hoods are commonly used in local kitchens, use of this equipment alone could not reduce greasy fumes to acceptable levels. Some designs combine a water spray hood with an air washer for control of greasy fumes. The performance of water spray hoods and air washers is directly related to the design of the equipment. If they are not properly designed, they will not be able to remove greasy fumes effectively. Therefore, in the design of water spray hoods, it is necessary to ensure that the nozzles used in the hoods are capable of creating fine water mist and will not easily get clogged.

When designing water spray hoods and air washers, the following issues should be considered:
• Avoid leakage of greasy fumes from any gaps.
• Allow sufficient residence time.
• Provide adequate air-to-water-ratio.
• Select appropriate scrubbents.
• Ensure that the equipment is easy to maintain and clean.
To ensure efficient greasy fumes removal, hotels should frequently clean the nozzles and replenish the scrubbents.

(Photo 3.11) Packed scrubber is less efficient and requires more space when compared with electrostatic precipitator.


c. Packed Scrubber


Packed scrubbers remove greasy fumes and odours by spraying scrubbent over the incoming exhaust air. The scrubber
must be filled with specially designed packing materials to increase contact surface area and hence enhancing the scrubbing efficiency. In comparison with water spray hoods and air washers, packed scrubbers can remove greasy fumes and odours more effectively. However, when compared with EPs, packed scrubbers are less efficient and require more space.

Comparison among common types of greasy fume control equipment:

 
Greasy fume removal
efficiency
Odour removal
efficiency
Advantages
Disadvantage

Electrostatic Precipitators with Water Spray Hood


   

High efficiency in removal of greasy fumes with auto cleaning function


-----

Electrostatic Precipitators
   
High efficiency in removal of greasy fumes if maintained properly For duct type, the maintenance will be difficult. For hood type with modular design, all major components can be removed for maintenance and cleaning easily
Water Spray Hoods
 
   
Need to be used with other control equipment in order to be efficient in greasy fume control Cannot remove oily mist effectively
Air Washers
   
   
Need to be used with other control equipment in order to be efficient in greasy fume control -----
Packed Scrubbers
 
 
Can remove odour effectively if suitable scrubbing agent is used Usually occupy more space
 

Case Studies

a. Case study 3.1 – A Hotel in Hawaii, U.S.A


A Hotel in Hawaii, U.S.A. is phasing out its use of CFC and HCFC refrigerants by 2005. The first step was the installation of special refrigerant management software in 1998 to organise and control the refrigerant inventory. The next step involved identifying existing equipment, which used CFC and HCFC refrigerants and beginning the phase-out plan.


The hotel’s most significant investment has been the replacement of its original chillers (operated on CFC-11) with two 450-ton chillers operating with HFC-134A with flexible options for future improved refrigerants. At current utility prices, the new chillers – with variable speed/ frequency drive motors and a lower kW per ton rating – result in an estimated annual saving of US$75,000, with a projected return on investment of 4.7 years.

(Source: Green Hotelier Issue No. 21 January 2001)

 

b. Case study 3.2 – Hotels in Macao, China


Hotels using “heavy fuel oil” powered boilers with 2.5-3% sulphur content would require greater effort in boiler maintenance and emission controls such as frequent black ash removal, installation of control devices, etc.. Hotels using “diesel” powered boilers with < 0.5% sulphur content claimed that the relatively higher price paid for “diesel” is recoverable through manpower saving in maintenance, ash cleaning and saving in emission control.


In kitchen, water spray hoods and air washers are commonly used for control of oily fume and cooking odour from the kitchen operation.


(Source: Macao Hotel Environmental Survey in 2003)